Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V LEAL (2) (81 M.J. 613) | Upon return of the case, the Convening Authority referred two specifications to a special court-martial (Leal II) based on the same underlying conduct: one alleging assault consummated
by a battery in violation of Article 128, UCMJ, and one alleging maltreatment in violation of Article 93, UCMJ. A panel of officer and enlisted members acquitted Appellant of assault, but convicted him, contrary to his pleas, of maltreatment. The members sentenced Appellant to reduction to E-5 and restriction for fifteen days, which the Convening Authority approved.
Appellant now raises three issues for our consideration:
1) Whether the military judge violated Appellant’s Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights by not allowing his counsel to examine the members during a post-trial session under Article 39(a), UCMJ;
2) Whether the military judge failed to develop an adequate record into alleged unlawful command influence during deliberations and abused her discretion by denying a motion for mistrial; and
3) Whether Appellant is entitled to relief for unreasonable post-trial delay
We find no merit in the first issue, but we agree with Appellant that there is an inadequate record into whether unlawful command influence tainted deliberations and that unreasonable post-trial delay warrants relief. Based on both errors and the circumstances of this particular case, we set aside the findings and sentence. | Docket No. 1470 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 5/3/2021 | 5/3/2021 | | 5/4/2021 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V GREENING - 54 MJ 831 | UNITED STATES VV GREENING - 54 MJ 831 - Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals Decision | Docket No. 1137 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 3/28/2001 | 3/28/2001 | | 8/31/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V ZOBITZ - UNPUBLISHED | UNITED STATES V ZOBITZ - UNPUBLISHED
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals - Opinion | Docket No. 1341 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 4/6/2011 | 4/6/2011 | | 9/18/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | United States V YODER (UNPLISHED) | United States V YODER (UNPLISHED)
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals Opinion | Docket No. 001-62-13 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 9/9/2013 | 9/9/2013 | | 9/18/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V WOOLDRIDGE - 49 MJ 513 | UNITED STATES V WOOLDRIDGE - 49 MJ 513 | Docket No. 1092 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 12/1/1998 | 12/1/1998 | | 8/29/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V WILSON - UNPUBLISHED | UNITED STATES V WILSON - UNPUBLISHED
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals Opinion | Docket No. 1435 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 5/1/2017 | 5/1/2017 | | 9/1/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V WILLIAMS - JR - 54 MJ 757 | UNITED STATES V WILLIAMS - JR - 54 MJ 757- Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals Decision | Docket No. 1140 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 2/7/2001 | 2/7/2001 | | 8/31/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V WILLIAMS - UNPUBLISHED | UNITED STATES V WILLIAMS - Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals Decision | Docket No. 1084 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 9/26/1997 | 9/26/1997 | | 8/25/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V WHITE - UNPUBLISHED | UNITED STATES V WHITE - UNPUBLISHED - Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals Decision | Docket No. 1146 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 7/17/2001 | 7/17/2001 | | 8/31/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V WHITAKER - UNPUBLISHED | UNITED STATES V WHITAKER - UNPUBLISHED
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals Order | Docket No. 1366 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 2/19/2014 | 2/19/2014 | | 9/18/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V WEST - 56 MJ 626 | UNITED STATES V WEST - 56 MJ 626
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals Decision | Docket No. 1145 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 10/28/2001 | 10/28/2001 | | 8/31/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V WEBER - 56 MJ 736 | UNITED STATES V WEBER - 56 MJ 736
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals Decision | Docket No. 1151 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 1/23/2002 | 1/23/2002 | | 8/31/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES v VANWINKLE (UNPULBLISHED) | UNITED STATES v VANWINKLE (UNPULBLISHED)
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals Opinion | Docket No. 1386 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 3/13/2015 | 3/15/2015 | | 9/15/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V TWOMLEY - UNPUBLISHED | UNITED STATES V TWOMLEY - UNPUBLISHED
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | Docket No. 1412 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 4/18/2016 | 4/18/2016 | | 9/1/2017 |
Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | UNITED STATES V TUALLA (TUALLA II) - 53 MJ 610 | UNITED STATES V TUALLA (TUALLA II) - 53 MJ 610 - Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeal Decision | Docket No. 1079 | Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals | 6/6/2000 | 6/6/2000 | | 8/30/2017 |