Probationary Period - Appeal Rights
The probationary period should be used to determine an employee’s fitness
for continued employment in the federal government. Generally, the
probationary period is the first year of service for an employee in the
competitive service; however it is not quite that simple. It is the first
year of service of an individual in the competitive service that is given a
career or career-conditional appointment when the employee was either
appointed from a competitive list of eligibles or was reinstated, unless the
reinstated employee previously completed a probationary period or served
with competitive status under an appointment that did not require a
A probationary employee has limited rights when appealing a termination
to the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB). The right to appeal a removal
during a probationary period to the Board will depend on whether an employee
meets the definition of an “employee” under the law and whether he/she meets
the requirements of any OPM regulation that grants additional appeal rights.
Whether someone is an “employee” with appeal rights will depend in part on
whether he/she is in the competitive service or the excepted service. This
information can be found on the employee’s Standard Form 50. Generally, a
probationary employee is excluded from the definition of “employee” in the
competitive service and excepted service. Case law helps guide how a
termination during the probationary period is handled.
- Prior service under a temporary limited appointment can count toward
completion of a probationary period. Therefore, it is important to
consult with the Office of Civilian Human Resources to ensure that an
employee is currently serving a probationary period. In the competitive
service, this time counts if it was:
- 1) rendered immediately prior to the career or
career-conditional appointment or conversion;
- 2) in the same line of work;
- 3) in the same agency; and
- 4) with no more than one break in service of less than 30 days.
- Competitive Service:
- An individual in the competitive service terminated during the
probationary period will have limited appeal rights. An employee may
appeal to the Board if he/she believes the termination was based on
(a) partisan political reasons, or (b) marital status. The employee
may also appeal if he/she believes the termination was based on
discrimination because of race, color, religion, sex, national
origin, age, or physical or mental disability, but only if the
allegation of such discrimination is raised in addition to (a) or
(b) mentioned above.
- An employee in competitive service who has completed one year of
current continuous service under other than a temporary appointment
limited to one year or less will have full appeal rights to the
- Excepted Service:
- Except for an employee serving under a Veterans’ Recruitment
Appointment (VRA), an employee serving under excepted service has no
appeal rights to the MSPB. A VRA appointee terminated during a
probationary or trial period has the right to appeal to the MSPB.
VRA appointees are the only excepted service appointees who have the
same appeal rights as competitive service appointees.
- Prior federal civilian service counts toward completion of the
probationary period when the prior service:
- is in the same agency;
- is in the same line of work (as determined by the employee’s
actual duties and responsibilities); and
- contains a break in service not exceeding 30 calendar days.
- A supervisor shall utilize the probationary period as fully as
possible to determine the fitness of the employee and shall terminate
the employee’s services during this period if he/she fails to
demonstrate fully his/her qualifications for continued employment.
- If it is determined that a probationary employee is unsatisfactory
in either performance or conduct, he/she may be terminated at any time
during the probationary period. The effective date must be prior to the
end of the probationary period.
- The probationary/trial period should always be considered a key
period for addressing and resolving performance issues. The lapse of a
probationary/trial period without a proper assessment of a new
employee's performance may result in future performance problems; at
which time the employee will have full MSPB appeal rights.